Goods fraud and CIT in Poland – when does a fraudulent transaction not generate taxable revenue?
18 November 2026
18 November 2026

In a case of goods fraud and CIT in Poland, the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) held on 26 June 2026 (II FSK 838/25) that no revenue due arose where fraudsters impersonating a customer obtained goods and the legitimate customer neither contracted nor received them. The sales proceeds never received are still not a tax-deductible expense, and the ruling does not cover ordinary non-payment for a genuine sale.
The treatment of goods fraud and CIT in Poland matters to businesses selling on credit, particularly across borders, because a supplier whose customer fails to pay must generally still recognise taxable revenue. The position may differ where no genuine sale took place because the goods were obtained by someone impersonating a legitimate customer.
In this article:
A Polish manufacturer of refrigeration equipment received an order from an individual claiming to be the commercial director of a French company. It checked the customer’s registration details and VIES status, obtained a PLN 200,000 credit limit from its trade credit insurer, and delivered equipment worth PLN 87,527.85 (EUR 19,474) to a designated warehouse in France.
After the payment deadline, the French company denied ordering or receiving anything. The signature and stamp were not its own, and the warehouse was not operated by it. The supplier reported the matter to law enforcement and applied to the Director of the National Tax Information (KIS) for confirmation that it need not recognise revenue.
Not necessarily. Under Article 12(3) of the CIT Act, revenue includes amounts due even where payment has not been received, so non-payment of a genuine sale generally does not remove the obligation to recognise revenue. The decisive question is whether the supplier has an enforceable receivable arising from an actual sale.
The NSA found that the legitimate customer had not placed the order or received the goods, so the invoice did not document a genuine sale and the supplier had no enforceable claim against the customer named on it. The judgment rested on Article 12(3), read together with Article 12(3a), not on a general exclusion of transactions connected with criminal activity.
Fraud may give rise to a separate claim for the return of goods or compensation for damages, but this does not automatically create revenue due from the originally intended sale.
This outcome applies to the case examined and is not a general interpretation covering every instance of commercial fraud.
No, as far as lost sales proceeds are concerned. Revenue never earned is not an expense incurred to generate revenue and so does not meet Article 15(1) of the CIT Act, a point KIS maintained in its new ruling. The actual costs of purchasing or manufacturing the lost goods require a separate assessment, which the NSA did not comprehensively determine.
VAT must also be assessed separately. In judgment I FSK 1641/23 of 7 May 2026 the NSA found no taxable supply in that case, but CIT conclusions should not automatically be applied to VAT.
A supplier should preserve records that show why no genuine sale occurred, since merely presenting an unpaid invoice is not sufficient. Relevant evidence may include:
The NSA did not make the absence of revenue due conditional on completing criminal proceedings. However, ruling proceedings rely on the facts presented by the applicant, and the actual course of events may be verified in later tax proceedings.
Goods fraud and CIT in Poland – when does a fraudulent transaction not generate taxable revenue?
If you have any further questions or require additional information, please contact your business relationship person or use the enquiry form on the HLB Poland website.
***
Download the brochures providing general information and outlining the services that are offered by HLB member firms.
Learn moreClick below for more detailed information regarding population, major towns and cities, language, religion and holidays in Poland.
Learn more